BEETLEJUICE BEETLEJUICE
I
was worried about this film.
The
trailers looked and felt like the frantic and flailing treading of
water that comes from trying to recapture something elusive. The vibe
felt like a court-mandated truce between practical elements and
digital tech that would never dream of talking shit about one another
even as they never seemed to mesh in a visually cohesive manner. The
haphazard projection of the press screening (in the wrong aspect
ratio) leaves a few questions in place about how exactly this film is
supposed to look- but real talk: I had enough of a good time that
I’ll happily check it out again. Will it become the perennial
family favorite that the first one did? Well, it’s too soon to say.
But it’s not a Greatest Hits movie, and it does cave in under the
weight of previous elements.
If
anything, what Beetlejuice Beetlejuice most reminds me of is
The Last Jedi. I didn’t love everything about that film,
either, but it felt so distinctive compared to its predecessor, and
so willing to make its own choices that it felt special. And time has
burnished its controversial reputation, and validated most of its
risks. And to call a legacy sequel with tie-in car insurance/sales
ads (including one with a “Day-O” rewrite that was so awful it
almost killed off any desire I had to see this film) risky is
certainly a wild development. But Beetlejuice Beetlejuice
doesn’t feel particularly safe or conventional.
It’s
hard to recapture how the original film played back in ‘88. First
at the Dayton Mall cinemas with my Dad, a second time at a long since
gone drive-in in Gallatin (with Flowers In The Attic as the
back half of the double feature!), there were elements that certainly
clicked through (I was already on board the Tim Burton train because
of Pee-Wee’s Big Adventure, which is absolutely the best
movie for an eleven year-old to have on repeat when recovering from
having an emergency tonsillectomy). But the O.G. Beetlejuice
is a mood, and absolutely a hangout film that derives power from
multiple viewings. There is a strength in the ramshackle, and this
lesson is the direct throughline from the 1988 original to this weird
little bauble of a film.
Once
again, Catherine O’Hara defines the film and gets the best lines
and the outfits that stick in your mind forever. Nothing as
epoch-defining as her opera gloves-as-headband in 1988,
but thanks to the media footprint of Schitt’s
Creek, the whole
world knows that no one wears clothes like O’Hara. Given the way
that Nightmare
Before Christmas-themed
accessories
have
become their
own perennial industry, is it too much to ask for Delia Deetz merch
from her Human Canvas installation (which
we see just enough of to be completely captivated)?
It
is the character of Delia and her entrenchment in the art world that
leads to the visual keystone of the whole film- that gorgeous,
asymmetrical house; born of Maitland Hardware and the paranormal
couture of Otho and Delia, a fusion of aesthetics that, in the
intervening almost four decades, has become one of the defining movie
homes of the ‘80s. That house, shrouded in mourning vestments, is
both a conceptual marvel and emotional grounding (as well as a tip of
the hat to Christo and Jean-Claude), and it helps the various and
sundry pieces of the film cohere. Do I wish it had the glorious
queer scalpel of the late, great Glenn Shadix’ voice? Absolutely.
(You can tell that Delia has inherited all the would-have-been Otho
lines, which is as it should be.) As for the Jeffrey Jones-shaped
hole in the film, it’s a Schrรถdinger’s
Cat approach to the character of Charles Deetz
The
biggest gamble that the film takes, other than existing in the first
place, is in Winona Ryder’s Lydia. In the original film, she is
ground zero for multiple generations to find themselves in Byronic
flourish and skill with a withering quip. Lydia is both mirror and
aspiration for everyone mortified by the tyranny of family tradition,
and she is perfect. Which makes depicting the passage of time and how
it has changed this pure Gen X icon both incredibly gutsy and kind of
shocking. Still blessed/cursed with the gift of seeing the dead, the
passing years have found her monetizing her specialness, dabbling in
a vague pill habit (a subplot that is left dangerously
underexplained), and caught in the orbit of a manager/lover (Justin
Theroux, who is pitched at 120% but somehow only able to output on a
“mellow” setting) who exhibits different facets of the madcap
control freak that still haunt her from her time as the reluctant
would-be bride of Beetlejuice.
Burton
understands that too much Beetlejuice tips the scales, and
thankfully, Keaton pops up in exactly the right proportion to the
runtime. His undead Tex Avery vibe works best as a gag machine that
can be fit into the story whenever he’s called on, and it’s
comparable to the first film’s similarly judicious use of the
character.
As
Lydia’s daughter Astrid, Jenna Ortega is in a very interesting
narrative space. She has to incarnate several recent generations,
including the skepticism that Millennials and Gen Z rightfully feel
toward everything that has come before, as well as define the voice
of petulant youth – these aspects give her a strong voice and a
rock solid foundation, but they don’t let her be a whole lot of
fun. Which, honestly, is a fair reflection of the world around us and
what previous generations have done with it. Thankfully, Astrid gets
her own storyline that lets her have some terror-filled adventures,
including a first date and a multidimensional caper that allows for
some reconciliations (both emotionally and cosmically), in addition
to a possibly unintentional narrative point that susceptibility to
supernatural subterfuge may be a genetically dominant trait.
There’s
also Willem Dafoe as the ghost of an actor famous for playing a cop
who, in the afterlife, has become a high-ranking detective (it’s
easier to enjoy onscreen than it is to explain- he’s probably the
closest equivalent we have to Sylvia Sidney’s Juno in that he sets
the tone we have for the bureaucracy of The Other Side), and he has a
mad joie de vivre that helps reinforce some of the more tangential
aspects of the script. Real talk: it’s a very weird choice to have
Monica Bellucci in your movie and give her absolutely nothing to do.
She has an iconic look, and gets to dole out the gnarliest kills, and
it still feels like she’s barely in the film. This is the Eva
Green/Helena Bonham Carter/Lisa Marie part, and it will likewise fuel
a thousand Halloween costumes. It’s also an unexpected weird little
treat to find Torchwood/Pacific Rim’s Burn Gorman
meshing into the proceedings as a Connecticut priest whose
interaction with the realm of the undead feels like it could be
setting up a wacky take on Nightbreed’s Father Ashbury in
the future.
Easily
Burton’s best film since Frankenweenie (and before that,
Sleepy Hollow), this manages to finally fix the catastrophic
legacy of Big Fish- here is Burton finding a path to
reconciling generations without completely belt-sanding away the
edges that made his work distinctive in the first place.
This
film’s musical setpiece may be the Richard Harris “MacArthur
Park,” but thankfully, we’re bookended with the sublime Donna
Summer version. Aesthetically, we’re in good hands.